My cash flow and investment choices are about to take a major swing.  Purchasing a home will ultimately mean less money wasted each month but will also result in a smaller liquid, investable monthly cash flow.  I define money wasted by spent money that returns a neutral or negative ROI (i.e. a depreciating asset or pure expense).

Rent is a pure expense.  When you send in the check you immediately lose 100% of your money — it is not an investment in any way.  Similarly, when buying a home mortgage interest and property taxes are mostly wasted — but not 100% due to tax deductions.  The effect of the tax deductions will vary based upon the individual’s tax rate and how much house you are buying (because you can only account deductions above and beyond what you would have gotten by taking the standard deduction in any renting vs. buying debate), but I’ll summarize it as approximately an 80% waste for my situation. PMI and hazard insurance are also pure expenses.

Here is my new expected total cash flow:

Expense Amount
Mortgage Interest $635.58
HELOC Interest $147.33
Property Taxes $354
Hazard Insurance $59.08
Trash $26
Water $25
PG&E $50
Car Insurance $45
Car registration $4
Gas $63.52
Tolls $21.65
Groceries $100
Vitamins $10
Home Maintenance $20
Car Maintenance $10
Clothes $10
Misc. (toiletries, cleaning supplies) $10
Total Necessities $1532.08
Internet $25
Basic cable $10
Entertainment $100
Total Expenses $1667.08

 

Income/Saving Amount
Post-retirement-contribution Salary $3,701.43
Net other income $935
Total Net Income $4,636.43
Mortgage Principle $1,226.50
HELOC Principle $39.92
401k $1416.67
Roth IRA $416.67
Investible income (left over after bills/contributions) $1702.93
Total Savings $4,802.69

 

The trash pickup is the only utility that I have an exact quote for; the others are estimates.  I have already arranged a 3 person car pool with 2 of my coworkers which explains the lower than expected commuting costs.  I am also expecting to trade in my Acura for a used Prius which further explains the savings.  I am going to pay for approximately two tolls per week in the carpool lane which comes out to 2*$2.50*4.33 = $21.75/month.  I’ll be driving about 58 miles for 2 days per week, 20 miles another 2 days a week and working from home one day per week which comes out to $63.52/month.  Once again, both of these numbers are conservative over-estimates as I will actually be driving the full distance only 1.67 days/week.

Many of my expenses are much lower than average because of buying durable items, treating them well and DIY ethics.  My house is relatively new and has recently been fully remodeled with virtually no problems popping up on my home inspection.  I also plan on buying a very reliable used Prius which doesn’t require as much habitual maintenance costs because of the hybrid engine and my careful driving.  And when something does pop up, I’ll fix it myself rather than outsourcing.  Also noticeably absent from my expenses is a cell phone bill.  I am on my family’s plan, but I’ve decided that I hardly use my cell phone as is, so if they weren’t paying for it, I’d just use Skype and Google voice.  I could even keep my iPhone as a portable wifi phone.  In the worst case I could follow MMM’s plan for $10/month cell phones.  Finally, I don’t have any budget for healthcare costs because I get to stay on my family’s plan for 2 more years for free.  Eventually this will be $50/month or so after tax deductions if I decide to participate in my employer’s plan.  However, I believe in living a healthy lifestyle and practicing prevention rather than expensive treatment of lifestyle diseases.

The salary number is an estimate derived after taking maximum 401k contributions, employer matching, and maximum Roth IRA contributions into account.  I arrived at the number by the following: $85,650 base salary * 0.04 = $3,426 employer contribution.  $17,000 maximum 401k contribution – $3,426 = $13,574 pre-tax contribution.  $13,574/$85,650 = 15.85% pre-tax contribution.  Plugging that into the California Paycheck Calculator produces a monthly net income estimate of $4,118.10.  $4,118.10 – $416.67 = $3,701.43 post-401k, post-Roth salary.

It is important to note that this is a very conservative cash flow estimate for 2 reasons:

  1. It doesn’t take into account any of the benefits of homeownership deductions (I will be getting a decent tax refund check each year as I file single and 1)
  2. It doesn’t take into account my expected bonus of 15%

Now the amazing thing about this cash flow is that even in the extremely conservative stance I took, my total monthly savings will be GREATER THAN my take-home pay or total net income.  I effectively have a $4,802.69/$4,636.43 = 103.59% savings rate!  Of course this is possible by the magic of employer matching + tax deduction of 401k contributions.  So max those 401ks!  Now the catch is that I am technically not financially independent because my net expenses exceed my other passive income by $1667.08 – $935 = $732.08.  So if I became extremely hardcore by stopping retirement contributions and refinancing both mortgages to interest-only, I would only need $732.08/month in additional passive income to become financially independent.  At the 4% safe withdrawal rate (SFW), this would require ($732.08*12)/0.04 = $201,624 more savings.  For simplicity, if we assume no early withdrawal penalty  on retirement savings and balance it with no investment return on the savings, this would take $219,624/$4,802.69 = 45.73 months or bit over 3.5 years to financial independence; theoretically I could retire before my 28th birthday.


8 Comments

  1. Mason
    Posted October 17, 2012 at 9:29 am | Permalink

    I noticed this comment above and I believe there was an oversight regarding your maximum 401k contributions.

    Quote:
    “$17,000 maximum 401k contribution – $3,426 = $13,574 pre-tax contribution”

    You personally can contribute up to $17000. Your employer can contribute in excess of that $17000 personal maximum up to a total of $33000. So, the maximum personal + employer 401k contributions you can contribute yearly is $50000 (from what I have read). So, you don’t have to subtract your employer’s contributions from your own to reach a total of $17000. You can contribute more now and save even more if you like!

  2. Sean
    Posted October 17, 2012 at 10:23 am | Permalink

    I noticed you didn’t include the early withdrawl penalties. I’m horrible at math but would it be a better idea just to contribute up to get the employer match in the 401k and then the rest in taxable accounts?

    Assume you’re not going to just let this money sit and start withdrawling it before 30 years old?

    • Lee
      Posted October 19, 2012 at 8:58 am | Permalink

      There is a way around the early withdrawal penalty with Rule 72(t). Basically you can set up equal distributions based on your life expectancy, so retiring at 28 will mean pretty small distributions. The benefit is that you may be able to get by without paying any income tax on the distribution as you can keep them below the standard deduction + personal exemption. Of course, you can also withdraw Roth IRA contributions at any time tax and penalty free. However, in my opinion, the best way to retire very early is to buy a house with at least 3 bedrooms in an affordable location and rent out the other 2 rooms. The renters will cover all the wasted expense of home ownership (interest, insurance, PMI and property taxes) and maybe even some of the principle depending on the situation. Of course you could also do an interest-only loan and perhaps get paid to live in your own house.

  3. Scott
    Posted October 17, 2012 at 8:42 pm | Permalink

    I admire your enthusiasm. Aiming to save 103% of your net after-tax earnings is super super aggressive and extremely rare. If you can keep it up, you will be very wealthy indeed.

    I would warn you about some of your assumptions, as they may not hold up over time.

    $10/month for clothes, $100/month for food total, $10/month for car maintenance (for a Prius!), $63.52/month for gas….

    Those are all extremely small numbers that do not match what most Americans pay. How do you figure $100/month for food? That’s $25 a week. Most people drop that amount in a single visit to a restaurant.

    And $10 a month for clothes. Again, the cost of a single t-shirt. Over the course of a year, you will need 1-2 new pairs of shoes alone and that’s your entire clothing budget.

    And do you think you could repair a Prius yourself? No, if anything happens, that will be a $300-$600 bill. Many years of your budget worth in a single repair visit. Heck, cars need new tires every 5 years that cost $200 at the low end.

    Again, I do wish you the best of luck. And save as much as you can as young as you can to take advantage of compound interest, but I doubt in 1 year your budget will be as low as this. Try doubling it to start.

    • Lee
      Posted October 19, 2012 at 9:14 am | Permalink

      $10 a month for clothes is a deceiving number because I’m only counting clothes that I buy. If you tallied up all the clothes that are bought for me every year, it would probably be around $100 a month as my family tends to buy me a lot of stuff for Christmas/b-day gifts. Of course, if I were buying everything in this category myself, it would be much higher, but not 100/month. Probably about $30 – $50/month would be a reasonable estimate.

      $100 for food is actually pretty easy once you get the hang of it. When I started this blog, I thought I ate pretty cheaply and my budget was $250/month. As I started to read more MMM and ERE articles, I realized just how cheap making good food from scratch yourself can be. I eat a lot of enriched pasta ($1 for 1700 calories at Trader Joe’s), beans from 10 lb pags, non-processed oatmeal, cheese, olive oil, lettuce, tomatoes, and meat when I find good buys (never red meat though). $100/month comes out to a little over a dollar per meal — note that I don’t include restaurants, that is in the entertainment category.

      $10/month for car maintenance may be a bit low, only time will tell. I do think tires can last a decade if you take very good care of them and don’t drive excessively. $63.52 for gas is exact calculation of my work commute at 50 mpg in the Prius. It’s a bit conservative because I can hypermile the Prius to 55mpg+. I never regularly drive anywhere other than work. Grocery store trips are done by walking or biking, and when I do need to buy something, I usually buy online so that it is shipped to my house. Other driving (for travel) is also considered in the entertainment category.

  4. James
    Posted October 18, 2012 at 4:20 pm | Permalink

    Lee,

    I’m curious to know what your outlook is on renting when the total cost of rent is less than the cost of accumulated expenses such as mortgage interest, HELOC interest, Property taxes and Hazard Insurance. Would you consider it worthwhile to rent when the alternative is purchasing a house with greater interest and insurance expenses? I know you prefaced by saying that not 100% of the interest expense is totally wasted due to tax incentives, but I am curious to know if there is a magic point where rental *is* actually more beneficial than having a mortgage. I’m at that place in my life where I’ve considered buying a house, but I can never quite justify the purchase, since, in most scenarios that I’ve considered my interest/taxes/insurance ends up being more expensive than my current living situation. Great blog, I’m learning a lot.

    • Lee
      Posted October 19, 2012 at 10:15 am | Permalink

      Hi James, the question of renting vs. buying largely depends on the ratio of average house cost/average rent. In the SF bay area, it doesn’t make any financial sense to buy in the Peninsula or the city, but the East Bay where I just bought is much cheaper. It’s also important to remember that rents rise over time with inflation while your house payment will stay the same (except for maybe property taxes, but in CA even those don’t rise until sale or renovation) and over the long run, your house will rise in value with inflation as well. At the same time, the percentage of your total house payment that is wasted will decrease as you pay down more of the principle so that more and more of your payment will go directly into equity in your house rather than to bankers. Unless you happen upon a significantly under-valued or over-valued home, this principle contribution will maintain its value by keeping up with inflation via house appreciation. You probably could beat this return in the stock market so there is some opportunity cost assuming the total PITI > total rent + renter’s insurance which has to be factored in. Lastly, you can also rent out a bedroom of your house that can push owning definitively above renting. In most areas of the country, I really believe that owning is the better decision, but you’ll have to run all the numbers for your individual situation to make sure.

      Of course, I also get a great psychological benefit of renting. I’ve only owned a house for 2 days now, but it is the best feeling in the world. It’s a feeling of real accomplishment, satisfaction of having no one to answer to, and the feeling that you really belong in a place for the long term. It’s also much more peaceful and quiet than my old apartment complex. Hope all this helps :)

4 Trackbacks

  1. By All Expenses are Optional | LeeOnLife on October 24, 2012 at 9:25 pm

    [...] my last post describing my new cash flow, I implicitly split my expenses into two categories: necessities and luxuries.  The luxuries were [...]

  2. By Where I expect to be in 15 years | LeeOnLife on November 1, 2012 at 9:40 am

    [...] – $1,215k = $3,875k.  This is the most aggressive speculation in this prediction.  With my current cash flow, I am only able to allocate about $1700 per month to other investments, and the total liquid value [...]

  3. By November Net Worth Update | LeeOnLife on November 6, 2012 at 11:49 am

    [...] It’s that time of the month again.  A lot has happened since my last update.  I closed on my house, paid some hefty closing costs and lease breakage fees, and paid for some one-time purchase appliances and general moving costs.  My house appraisal came in $10k higher than my purchase price, so that is the main reason in the larger than average boost this month.  This should be the last month of big swings before we get back to the roughly $4800 monthly savings as seen here. [...]

  4. [...] every young saver and investor has to make.  In my particular situation, I am debating between retiring at 28 and becoming a pentamillionaire by 39.  Either way I plan on retiring from working for someone [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*


two × 5 =

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>